FAN 165.2 (First Amendment News) Masses Publishing Co. v. Patten court documents now posted on First Amendment Library
Judge Learned Hand’s order granting the temporary injunction against the postmaster and ordering the magazine transmitted through the mails “without delay” was dated July 26, two days after the decision became known. During that brief period, the company pulled back the copies sent to the Post Office so the edition could be delivered by alternate means. On the same day the order was issued, U.S. Attorney Francis G. Caffey filed an Assignment of Error listing grounds on which he would rely in his appeal from Hand’s decree. In all, there were seven alleged errors, although essentially all of them went directly to the bottom line: Hand was wrong in finding for the magazine under every provision of the Espionage Act raised by government and wrong in granting the injunction. — Eric Easton, Defending the Masses (Jan. 2018)
* * * *
‘Tis the year of The Masses. This year marks the 100th anniversary of Judge Learned Hand’s seminal free-speech opinion in Masses Publishing Co. v. Patten. As previously reported here, two major events have been organized to celebrate the occasion.
→ New York Univeristy School of Law and the Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law at Arizona State University are hosting an all-day conference in New York on October 20th.
→ Not long thereafter, on November 6th, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, in association with The First Amendment Salons, the Floyd Abrams Institute for Freedom of Expression at Yale Law School, and the Media Law Committee of the New York State Bar Association, will host a “reargument” of the appeal in Masses Publishing Co. v. Patten. Floyd Abrams will appear on behalf of Postmaster Patten and Kathleen M. Sullivan will appear on behalf of Masses Publishing Co. The case will be argued before a panel of three judges:
- Circuit Judge Reena Raggi,
- Circuit Judge Pierre N. Leval, and
- Circuit Judge Robert D. Sack
Original court documents posted for first time
In light of all of the above, the folks over at the First Amendment Library (led by Jackie Farmer) have uploaded 18 never before posted documents relating to the appeal in The Masses case. Among other things, this compilation includes the complaint, various affidavits filed in the case, transcript of the record, the order staying Judge Hand’s injunction, and much more.
→ Adriana Mark, head of research and education for the Second Circuit Library, unearthed these documents for the First Amendment Library. The librarians at the Gallagher Library of the University of Washington School of Law also provided additional research.
Professor Eric Easton, author of Defending the Masses: A Progressive Lawyer’s Battles for Free Speech University of Wisconsin Press (Jan. 2018), kindly agreed to allow us to post a chapter from his forthcoming book, this to provide additional context for the documents posted.