FAN 42 (First Amendment News) Tribute to Al Bendich (1929-2015) — the ACLU lawyer who made the difference in the HOWL & Lenny Bruce cases

Al Bendich, April 5, 2013

Al Bendich, April 5, 2013

Some people make a difference in their lives; some people actually add to the bounty of freedom we call ours; and some people are so modest as to go quietly into the dark of their eternal night. Albert Bendich was one of those rare few. Sadly, Al died this past Monday.

Liberty in America is better off because of Al and what he did as a lawyer for the American Civil Liberties Union. He gave legal life to poetry and lawful voice to comedy . . . and more.

To know him was to like him — calm, mild mannered, soft spoken, and kind to a fault. But if you wanted to see sparks of passion — the ones that revealed the fire burning within him — all you had to do was start up a conversation about free speech. When it came to that, this lifetime defender of free expression became quite animated, but always with the composure of a learned lawyer who knew not only the law but also its history and the grand principles underlying it.

“I can’t think of anything more rewarding than fighting for matters of fundamental principles necessary to the preservation of democracy,” said Bendich in 2009. “The ACLU,” he added, “is absolutely necessary in that process. Without it we’d be going backward instead of trying to maintain our position and maybe inch a little bit forward.”

Al Bendich was a true inspiration to everyone in the ACLU community. . . From his time as staff counsel at the ACLU of Northern California, to his days as a teacher, and then a career in music and film with his colleague Saul Zaentz, Al’s passion for the Constitution and his country was a constant. — Abdi Soltani, Executive Director, ACLU of Northern California

The People vs Poetry 

Turn the clock back to 1957. On June 3rd of that year San Francisco police arrested Shig Murao, the manager of City Lights Bookstore, for selling HOWL and Other Poems to an undercover officer. Thereafter, City Lights’s publisher Lawrence Ferlinghetti was arrested for publishing HOWL. (See here and here for accounts of the arrest and what followed).  The case, People v. Ferlinghetti, went to trial.

The trio of defense counsel: the famed and flashy criminal defense lawyer Jake Ehrlich, the talented and knowledgeable public-interest lawyer Lawrence Speiser, and a recent Boalt Hall law graduate, Al Bendich (Speiser and Bendich were ACLU lawyers).

Here is how Nadine Strossen, the ACLU’s past President and a friend of Al’s, described what happened next:  “When Al Bendich worked on the landmark HOWL case, he was a very new lawyer, and the Supreme Court’s Roth decision, defining the obscenity exception to the First Amendment, was a very new decision. The HOWL case was one of first impression — the first actual application of Roth to an obscenity prosecution. Accordingly, Al’s brief in the case played a key role in shaping the law on point.”

“All free speech advocates,” she added, “are eternally indebted to Al for brilliantly managing to construe the Roth obscenity exception as narrowly as feasible, and persuasively explaining why it didn’t encompass HOWL. The brief had a palpable impact on the judge’s historic, speech-protective opinion, which in turn has had an ongoing positive impact on law and literature alike.”

Here is a passage from that brief:

Would there be any freedom of the press or speech if one must reduce his vocabularly to vapid and innocous euphemisms? An author should be real in treating his subject and be allowed to express his thoughts and ideas in his own words. Al Bendich (brief in People v. Ferlinghetti, 1957)

When it was all over, poetry prevailed.

Screen Shot 2015-01-05 at 10.56.30 PM

It was a new day in First Amendment America. HOWL could be sold in City Lights Bookstore and elsewhere. And all of this from a ruling by a San Francisco municipal court judge (Clayton W. Horn) who wrote a remarkable opinion that drew heavily on the work of a young ACLU lawyer named Al Bendich. Incredibly, it was the last time that a poem was the target of prosecution in an American court.

Even so, censors returned to the scene. Decades later, in 2005, Congress raised limits on the fines for indecency on the broadcast airwaves. That enabled the F.C.C. to charge up to $325,000 for every violation of its standards. And those standards barred reading HOWL on broadcast radio or television. “It seems like déjà vu all over again,” said Al.

Comedy on Trial

Imagine being busted for being a tad too colorful in telling jokes (many of them by way of social commentary) in a comedy club . . . in San Francisco . . . in the 1960s. Well, it happened to Lenny Bruce — no joke! The infamous comedian was hauled away from using indecent words during his performance at a club in North Beach in 1961 (see The Trials of Lenny Bruce).

The prosecutor was Hell bent on putting the “filthy” comedian behind bars for words spoken to adults at a joint called The Jazz Workshop where the likes of Thelonious Monk and others performed. No one was offended, no one complained, and no children were in the audience. Never mind. Bruce’s choice words violated sections 176 and 205 of the Municipal Police Code (unlawful presentation of an “obscene, indecent, immoral, or impure” performance) and section 311.6 of the California Penal Code (“lewd or obscene” words used in “any public place”). Now Lenny Bruce would have to face the music — and it wasn’t free-spirited jazz.

Al Bendich & Lenny Bruce at Bruce's 1961 SF obscenity trial

Al Bendich & Lenny Bruce at Bruce’s 1961 SF obscenity trial

Bruce had been looking around for a powerhouse mouthpiece, preferably someone who was “hip” to First Amendment law. Predictably, Al Bendich’s name came up. They met, they spoke, and soon enough Al agreed to defend the comedian on First Amendment grounds. So they went to trial.

The Judge? None other than Clayton Horn, the same judge who followed Bendich’s counsel and ruled in favor of Lawrence Ferlinghetti. Given the Horn-Bendich connection, things looked quite promising for Lenny. Ever the contrarian, Bruce demanded a jury trial. It was insanity. Still, Bendich preserved and thanks to several brilliant legal maneuvers was successful in securing a not guilty ruling.

photoHere is the kicker: the jury wanted to convict Bruce but ruled otherwise solely because of the precise jury instructions given to them by Judge Horn. Said one juror afterwards: “We hate this verdict, but under the instructions there was nothing we could do but give the ‘not guilty’ verdict.”

And who drafted those instructions? Yes, it was that same ACLU lawyer. Bendich had done it again; he had beaten back the forces of censorship. Now norm-breaking poetry and speak-your-mind comedy were safe in San Francisco.

* * * * 

There is, to be sure, more to Al Bendich’s life story than those two landmark First Amendment cases. There is, for example, his many years as counsel for Fantasy Records. And there is also his work on behalf of the constitutional rights of gays (see here, circa 1960), the poor, and the criminally accused.

My last conversation with Al Bendich was about the death penalty. His opposition was deep and passionate. His abiding sense of justice stemmed from multiple sources – his brilliant intellect; his commitment to the constitution and finally, his life experience.

He also spoke with his characteristic humility, but great pride, about his role in litigating one of the  most influential  cases establishing the unconstitutional conditions doctrine for recipients of public benefits, Parrish v. Civil Service Commission. In Parrish the California Supreme Court ruled in the 1960’s that predawn “bed raids” of recipients was a violation of their Fourth Amendment rights, and that the government could not condition continued receipt of public assistance on the forfeiture of constitutional rights. — Dorothy M. Ehrlich, Deputy Executive Director, national ACLU

Remember the First Amendment lawyers 

We think of First Amendment law as synonymous with judge-made law. We know the names of the judges — Holmes and Brandeis, Black and Brennan, etc. — who penned the famous opinions. But what of the lawyers who, like Al Bendich, argued those cases and advanced novel and persuasive arguments? Regrettably, too often they receive too little credit for the work they do. We must do more to remember them, to learn from them, and to share their life stories with new generations of lawyers eager to defend civil rights and civil liberties.

Now he stands tall in the memorial ranks of other First Amendment lawyers — the likes of everyone from Walter H. Pollak to Ephraim London to Stanley Fleishman to Bruce J. Ennis and beyond. They were, after all, the ones who helped to shape the law in ways to make the impossible possible. In the process they gave new and vibrant meaning to the First Amendment.

Farewell 

“Al Bendich contributed so much to the strong protection of free expression in the United States,” said Robert Corn-Revere, a noted First Amendment lawyer. “He had the vision and courage to defend speech that many people found to be unacceptable. I hope this sad occasion will at least move us to remember — and to celebrate — his accomplishments.”

With Al in 2013

With Al in 2013

On a personal note: Al was a dear friend. A year or so ago I was with him in Seattle with David Skover, whose law school hosted a conference at which Al spoke (see video here). And then there was the time when David and I spent a wondrous evening in San Francisco with Al and his wife Pam — chatting away for hours on everything from Alex Meiklejohn to Citizens United to Humanitarian Law ProjectDespite a few differences of views, Al picked up the tab (fancy wine and all). The sparkle in his eye, his gentle grin, his soft tone, and the way he spoke with such an admirable commitment to freedom — I remember it all as I write this.

In my mind’s eye I venture to City Lights Bookstore and see Al and Lawrence Ferlinghetti there — the lawyer and the poet — talking about the need for more insurgent poetry. And I imagine the tall poet leaning over to Al and saying: “Poetry is a radical presence constantly goading us.” Al smiles. “Ah yes, and remember,” he adds, “one of the reasons we have a First Amendment is to safeguard that radical presence.”

One final thought: If you believe in the work that Al Bendich did, if you believe in freedom for radical poets and ribald comics, and if you care about free speech in America, you can do something — exercise your First Amendment rights / help to protect the rights of others (even if you disagree with them) / and support the American Civil Liberties Union (go here to donate) or whatever group (liberal, conservative, or libertarian) that supports the principle of free speech for all.

Farewell Al.

Postscript: See also Michael Tigar, “Al Bendich, Mentor, Lawyer, Friend” (1-8-15)

You may also like...

25 Responses

  1. I’m really enjoying the design and layout of your blog.
    It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more enjoyable for me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire out a designer to create your theme?

    Fantastic work!

    Review my website – http://manyhacks.com/clash-of-clans-hack/

  2. Sabi Iohan says:

    wonderful issues altogether, you just won a logo new reader.
    What may you suggest in regards to your submit that you simply made some days in the past?
    Any certain?

  3. May I simply just say what a comfort to find someone that
    genuinely knows what they’re talking about over the internet.
    You certainly realize how to bring an issue to light and make
    it important. A lot more people really need to read this and understand this side of the story.
    I can’t believe you aren’t more popular given that you definitely possess the gift.

  4. Lon says:

    More than likely each of our kicker, Jer Hanson (that’s our best person incidentally), would be willing to stop trying his or her #4 jacket to create this particular
    happen. Congress, however, may lead to a repeal of that legislation this year.

    You do not have to be glued to a television screen to know how
    your favorite team is faring.

  5. Thanks, great information men. I am aware Raj Napal who has been a great law firm I understand, got acquired
    1000s of cases doing the job extremely tough. Tom turned is a highest
    rated lawyer within Europe.

    my web-site … criminal lawyers award contest

  6. Keith says:

    Including the school’s athletic director is also helpful if it is arrangeable.
    Psychological tools for releasing unwanted food habits. Below
    is the list of some essential skills required for the hockey coach.

  7. agen tangkas says:

    With Ladbrokes skill games, you can readily play betting games right from home or anywhere you want to.
    You could develop a casino meeting where the amount of business
    a salesperson brings in over a specified timeframe equates to receiving some
    chips that can be used during the sales meeting. ‘ #3 Caesars Palace Hotel and Casino claims
    to have more million dollar plus slot machine jackpots than any casino in the world.

  8. facebook says:

    Hello everyone, it’s my first go to see at this website, and post is in fact fruitful for me, keep up posting these types of articles.
    facebook
    facebook
    facebook

  9. youtube says:

    Hi, I do believe this is a great blog. I stumbledupon it
    😉 I’m going to come back yet again since i have bookmarked it.
    Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and
    continue to help others. youtube
    youtube

  10. instagram says:

    Its like you read my mind! You seem to know a lot
    about this, like you wrote the book in it or something.

    I think that you can do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but other than that, this is magnificent blog.
    An excellent read. I’ll certainly be back. instagram
    instagram

  11. 日刊ゲンダイが1面2面で特集たい目 メンズファッション 秋冬 30代 ヤンキー ショーでいくら奇抜でも実際に店頭に並ぶのはたいてい基本のデザインで一致するし
    「ファッションセンスを正してくれないのは本当の友人がいないからだ」子供六夜 アナルバイブ挿入したまま外出できるな
    そんなじーさまばーさまの薫陶の賜物なのだな。人間 制服姿の美しい教え子が、怒張を懸命に頬張っている姿は、刺激的すぎた。

    ユーモアに溢れた記事を書きたかったのではないだろうか思う一 農水大臣が表面的にせよ謝罪した相手の所を上役が訪問するのに
    そもそも男ものは買い替えのサイクルが長いからファヲタ取り込まないと売れない少し僕 社交ダンス メンズウェア 安いチノパンとかジーンズとポロシャツかシャツかTシャツ

  12. youtube says:

    It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d without a doubt donate to this excellent blog!
    I guess for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and
    adding your RSS feed to my Google account.
    I look forward to fresh updates and will talk about this blog with my Facebook group.
    Chat soon! youtube
    youtube
    youtube

  13. top music says:

    Hi, I log on to your new stuff on a regular basis. Your humoristic style is awesome,
    keep it up!

  14. These recorders also help it become faster and quicker
    to isolate certain times to review events without losing any recording
    time. These are certainly capable to supply very high volume of security and protection to your people and
    property. security cameras ebay cameras that run on batteries With assistance from CCTV footage, a
    large volume of people who commit crimes are caught.

    These look a great deal better compared to the wired versions
    of surveillance camera systems, while they do not need any
    loose or hanging wires to spoil the decor or perhaps the look of any place.
    Both of the take advantage from the digital quality and
    format with the transmission to keep the data inside a more compact way.

  15. twitter says:

    Wow, incredible weblog structure! How lengthy have you ever been running a blog
    for? you make running a blog glance easy. The total look of your web
    site is magnificent, let alone the content material! twitter
    twitter
    twitter

  16. Greate article. Keep writing such kind of info on your page.
    Im really impressed by it.
    Hello there, You have done an excellent job. I will definitely digg it
    and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.

  17. Don’t let kids play a game before you check its rating. Even though the ambiance might be great when your game takes place in dark caves or abandoned buildings,
    it really won’t help your performance much. Try to limit game play to under a couple of hours a day.

  18. If it is a extra everyday or rustic mood you are trying to create – less shine will
    glimpse superior. The new liner will in essence give you a new pool with previous measures and an old h2o slide.
    Then we can make your desire into fact with our qualified kitchen marble
    counter installation and kitchen reworking expert services in Toronto & GTA.

  19. Aw, this was a really good post. Spending some time and actual effort to make a superb article…
    but what can I say… I procrastinate a lot and don’t seem to
    get anything done.

    Here is my website – Qu’est-ce qu’on a fait au Bon Dieu film complet

  20. We are a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community.Your site offered us with valuable info to work on. You have done a formidable
    job and our whole community will be grateful to you.

    Feel free to surf to my page :: paid for online surveys

  21. Now, how many other mobile things 100% these websites like puzzle games,
    heroes of dragon age cheats top rated, action, puzzle, but will it take center stage as the
    the app. Whatever your preference may be and also avid bingo
    games on it and able to maximize heroes of dragon age cheats such amount of ladder.

  22. verse app says:

    I am regular reader, how are you everybody? This paragraph posted at this web page
    is genuinely fastidious.

    my web blog: verse app