US News Rankings – The Biggest Loser
Imagine if the input-based approach used by US News was applied to the TV show The Biggest Loser. Currently, contestants win the show if they lose the largest percentage of their body weight. The input (original weight) is controlled for by using a percentage decline in weight instead of focusing on actual final weight or actual pounds lost. A system like US News uses would not control for the original weight and would simply use the final weight, regardless of starting weight, as part of the metric of success. Even worse, the US News system would give bonus points in some form to people that started out lighter. In other words, a 120 lbs person who gains 20 lbs. would beat a 350 lbs. person who loses 150 lbs. in the bizarro-US-News-version of The Biggest Loser. In our world of law schools, deans do far better by attracting high-score students who ultimately don’t make good lawyers than low-score students who have better long-term success in the marketplace.