The Hand of God
As the World Cup begins (and a groove on my couch awaits), the thought occurred to me that the Justices are more comparable to those officials than (as Chief Justice Roberts famously said) to baseball umpires. Consider the following:
1. Umpires rarely change the outcomes of a game. Soccer referees do all the time.
2. Baseball is a rule-bound game. Soccer gives the referee lots of discretion (whether to award a penalty kick or not, whether to red card somebody or not, etc.)
3. Soccer fans often accuse the ref of being biased. You rarely hear that about umpires.
4. An umpire can have his call corrected by his colleagues. There is no appeal from a soccer referee’s decision.
Which of these sounds more like a Supreme Court Justice?