A Law Student’s Viewpoint on Contracts in the Real World
As promised, the following is contributed by my student, Umo O. Ironbar:
As a 1L student at Saint Louis University, reading the conditions materials in Professor Lawrence Cunningham’s Contracts in the Real World Stories of Popular Contracts was refreshing.
We looked at a deal that Kevin Costner went into for the creation of massive bronze bison sculptures which would be put in place in his luxury resort in South Dakota named The Dunbar (a tribute to his successful production of his 1990 movie “Dancing With Wolves). Another case we looked at was Charlie Sheen’s “play-or-pay” contract with Warner Brothers.
These cases are still so vivid in my mind because I actually knew who the parties were. Unlike other cases that could have been found in my regular contracts textbook, I did not have to wait until the notes and questions sections after the cases to know why these cases were so important or infamous, or why they made the selection into the textbook out of the hundreds of thousands of cases that have been tried.
I grew up watching Kevin Costner and Charlie Sheen on the big screen and television. They are both successful actors – and both had more than their share of controversy. When we read about Charlie Sheen our class was abuzz and more people wanted to speak and contribute to the class discussion. For me and many of my fellow classmates, the excitement came in part because Charlie Sheen was everywhere in the news and Internet. Everyone was just waiting to see what new eccentric behavior he was going show at any given time or day.
And here in my contracts class, we were actually talking about his legal issues. For me, it made the concepts we were learning more real. Conditions as defined by Restatement (Second) of Contracts, Section 224 made more sense to me. Conditions were no longer just words that were only used in law school academia.
I feel like many of the law students who will read Professor Cunningham’s contracts book will find it easier to follow the parties who are involved in the cases. Sometimes the biggest obstacle in understanding a case and what it is about is just being able to follow who the parties are and thus why they are in court. In using cases that involve people and stories we as students are familiar with, the materials make it easier for us to grasp the concepts and laws the courts are using to resolve breach of contract cases.