An Entertaining Opinion

If you want to see how to turn a dull case into a charming opinion, read Chief Justice Roberts’ decision (for a unanimous Court) in FCC v. AT&T (released today).

You may also like...

2 Responses

  1. Hillel Y. Levin says:

    Dull?! This is GOLD for a legislation course. It is a pretty decent example of “ordinary meaning” vs. grammar rule arguments, though I’m surprised that the Court didn’t muster any structural arguments to bolster its (obviously correct, in my opinion) conclusion.

  2. Sasha says:

    I really like this case (or at least, the interesting twist that it represents).

    Typically privacy advocates see the corporation as the bad guy. Afterall, they’re the ones collecting or disclosing PII without consent. My question for true privacy advocates arguing for stronger privacy rights is: is it difficult to reconcile that those rights may, one day, apply to corporations as well as consumers?