Ronald Reagan and Gay Rights
I wanted to follow up on my post on Monday reproducing Ronald Reagan’s 1978 op-ed against Proposition 6 (the “Briggs Amendment”), which would have barred gays from teaching in public schools.
The first thing that struck me was that Reagan linked his opposition to that measure to his opposition to another ballot measure that would have expanded state regulation of smoking. This libertarian rationale was probably intended to ward off criticism from social conservatives who supported Proposition 6 (and seems to have worked). (Personally, I agree with most of what the op-ed said about anti-smoking laws–I’m much more of a “live and let live” type in that respect, but that argument has not fared well over the past thirty years.)
Second, his argument against Proposition 6 was based in part on an overbreadth claim, especially with the measure’s language about prohibiting the advocacy of a gay lifestyle. Reagan correctly pointed out that this could curtail the free speech rights of teachers outside of the classroom (even for straight teachers) and should be rejected on that basis.
Finally, he made the point that sexual orientation is determined very early in life. He didn’t quite say that it was a inborn trait, but if you say that teachers don’t influence that much then that would imply that it must be set before you start school.
Anyway, the entire op-ed is definitely worth reading. That’s why I put it up.